| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
INRA, MYCSA (Mycologie et sécurité des aliments), BP 81, 33883 Villenave dOrnon cedex, France
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Agaricus specimens collected in France belong to two novel entities resembling small forms of A. moelleri and A. xanthodermus, two common species in section Xanthodermatei. Molecular (IT1+ITS2 DNA sequence) and morphological comparisons between eight presumed similar taxa of the section support the elevation of both entities to species rank. The new entities are described as A. parvitigrinus and A. xanthodermulus. They form a group with A. laskibarii, a rare species also recently described from France, and A. californicus, a North-American species. The well known A. moelleri and A. xanthodermus are the most related species among the studied sample. Like other species of the section, both new species have a phenolic odor and are probably toxic.
Key words: Basidiomycetes, Agaricus, section Xanthodermatei, ITS, systematics
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Dissimilarity analysis.
Analyses were performed with the tools available in Infobiogen (http://www.infobiogen.fr/index.html). Alignment was performed with version 1.8 of Clustal W (Higgins and Sharp 1988
). The distance matrix and the phenogram were performed with the DNADIST program (with the F84 model) and the Fitch program of the PHYLIP software package (Felsenstein 1993
).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
| TAXONOMY |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Pileus at first trapezoid-convex with the cap margin often pleated before the dehiscence, becoming truncately conical, later expanding to plano-convex with the discal part remaining flat, sometimes with low umbo; 1.65(6) cm diam and 45 mm thick; pilei-pellis uniformly bistre sepia at the center, gradually breaking up into appressed fibrillose squamules of less than 1 mm of width or length. These dark grayish squamules are scattered and well distinct from the white background. At maturity the center remains always bistre sepia, while the cap margin sometimes becomes completely white. On handling surface becomes yellow then ferruginous. Margin slightly exceeding the lamellae.
Lamellae free, ca. 14/cm at 1 cm from stipe, at first light pink, later grayish chocolate, margin not distinctive.
Stipe glabrous, often curved, subequal, progressively thicker toward the base that is bulbous, sometimes abruptly; 46(10) cm long x 35 mm thick (610 mm at the bulb); white becoming yellow then ferrugineous on handling; rhizomorphs sometimes visible.
Veils: universal veil not detected; partial veil thick, membranous, forming a pendant annulus, often with radial squamules on the underside, these occasionally arranged as a cogwheel; annulus sometimes loosened itself from the stipe.
Context white, light yellow when sectioned, fading away soon. The pileus easily breaking free from the stipe. Odor unpleasant, phenolic like ink. Schaeffer reaction negative.
Spores dark brown at maturity, cylindrical-ellipsoid, (4.6)5.56.7(7.4) x 3.44.4(5.2) µm, mean = 6.0 x 3.8 µm (N = 30 x 4), L/W = 1.61; apiculus visible. Basidia tetrasporic (some bisporic), clavate, 1825 x 79 µm; sterigmata 3 µm long. Cheilocystidia clavate to sphero-pedunculate, 1121 x 510 µm. Presence of pileipellis hyphae entirely colored by a light brown pigment apparently parietal incrusting; dark brown vacuoles lacking.
Characteristic internal transcriber spacer polymorphism. The four sequenced specimens of A. parvitigrinus (CA 157, CA 158, CA 176 and CA 212) have identical ITS1 and ITS2 sequences. Agaricus parvitigrinus can be distinguished from its three neighbor species, A. laskibarii L.A. Parra et Arrillaga, A. californicus Peck and A. xanthodermulus sp. nov. (see below), by ITS polymorphisms at positions 3638, 59, 120, 414 and 550 of its own sequence (respectively: ctggctTtCaggagc, gcctgtTtggact, ggaagcAggtcaa, cttggtGttccga and agaactAtttgcg).
Habitat, distribution, occurrence. Isolated, gregarious or caespitose in mixed deciduous wood (Carpinus, Robinia, Sambucus, Euonymus) on sandy alluvial soil. Western France, extent of range unknown, probably limited.
Specimens examined. All collections from mixed deciduous wood (Carpinus, Robinia, Sambucus, Euonymus), FRANCE, Gironde, Villandraut-Prechac: 21 Oct 2000, CA 277; 7 Oct 2001, CA 157, GENBANK xxx; 7 Oct 2001, CA 158, HOLOTYPE (LIP), GENBANK xxx; 27 Oct 2002, CA 176, GEN-BANK xxx; 15 Sep 2003, CA 212 GENBANK xxx. Mycelium cultures of CA 157, CA158 and CA 176 are available at INRA Bordeaux. All specimens were collected by J. Guinberteau; specimen CA 212 was collected with P. Callac and R.W. Kerrigan.
Etymology. The epithet parvitigrinus is a contraction of parvus and tigrinus that respectively refers to the small size of the sporophore and to the spotted aspect of the cap with colored squamules scattered on a white background, as in the case of Lentinus tigrinus.
Agaricus xanthodermulus Callac et Guinberteau, sp. nov. FIGS. 57
and 9
|
Pileus at first cuboidal, helmet-shaped, becoming truncately conical to conico-convex, opening slowly and irregularly, finally expanding to plano-convex remaining plane on the disc, sometimes with a low umbo; 1.55(6) cm diam, 45 mm thick; pileipellis smooth to subglabrous, uniformly white or gray, sensitive to the environment: often discoloring in grayish brown progressively from the top to the edge, sometimes breaking up into squamules and/or radially fissured. On handling surface becomes yellow. Margin exceeding the lamellae.
Lamellae free, ca 17/cm at 1 cm from stipe, at first light pink, later grayish chocolate, margin not distinctive.
Stipe glabrous, bumpy, satiny, often flexuous and curved at the base, subequal, progressively thicker toward the bulbous base, sometimes abruptly; 37(10) cm long x 37 mm thick (610 mm at the bulb); white, becoming yellow on handling; rhizomorphs sometimes visible.
Veils: universal veil not detected; partial veil thick, membranous, forming a pendant annulus, sometimes with radial squamules on the underside, these occasionally arranged as a cogwheel.
Context white, light yellow, more strongly so in the bulb when sectioned, soon fading. Odor unpleasant, phenolic, like ink. Schaeffer reaction negative.
Spores dark brown at maturity, ellipsoid to oblong, (5.7)6.67.8(8.6) x (4.0)4.55.5(6.3) µm, mean = 7.3 x 5.0 µm (N = 30 x 4), L/W = 1.46; apiculus visible. Basidia tetrasporic, cavate, 1827 x 68 µm; sterigmata 2.5 µm long. Cheilocystidia infrequent, clavate to spheropedunculate, sometimes in chains, 12 20 x 711 µm.
Characteristic internal transcriber spacer polymorphism. The four examined specimens of A. xanthodermulus (CA 160, CA 174, CA 188 and CA 204) have identical ITS1 and ITS2 sequences. Agaricus xanthodermulus can be distinguished from the three neighbor species, A. laskibarii L.A. Parra et Arrillaga, A. californicus Peck, and A. parvitigrinus sp. nov. (see above), by the characteristic ITS polymorphism tatgttTttcatt at position 222 of its own sequence.
Habitat, distribution, occurrence. Isolated to gregarious in mixed deciduous wood, in coniferous wood or in rich grassland, on sandy soil. Western France, extent of range unknown, possibly relatively abundant.
Specimens examined. FRANCE, Gironde, Villandraut-Prechac, mixed deciduous wood (Carpinus, Robinia, Sambucus, Euonymus), 7 Oct 2001, CA 160, J. Guinberteau, HOLOTYPE (LIP), GENBANK xxx; FRANCE, Charente Maritime, Oléron Island, rich grassland, 21 Oct 2002, CA 174, G. Dupuy, GENBANK xxx; FRANCE, Gironde, Le Verdon, under Pinus pinaster and Quercus ilex, 9 Nov 2002, CA 188, J. Guinberteau, GENBANK xxx; FRANCE, Charente Maritime, Oléron Island, rich grassland, 12 Nov 2002, CA 204, G. Dupuy, GENBANK xxx. Mycelium cultures of the four collection are available at INRA Bordeaux.
Etymology. The xanthodermulus epithet means small xanthodermus, indicating that the new species looks like a miniature A. xanthodermus.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The other small species of section Xanthodermatei described in Europe are A. pseudopratensis, A. endoxanthus and Psalliota nigricans. Agaricus pseudopratensis differs from both new species by its "stature squat, measurements resembling those of Agaricus campester" (Bohus 1971
) and by its context often becoming somewhat reddish. It also can be distinguished from A. xanthodermulus by its smaller spores. Agaricus endoxanthus differs from both new species by the presence of vacuoles containing an abundant dark brown pigment in the pileipellis hyphae; this also characterizes other small tropical species of the Xanthodermateilike A. rotalis K.R. Peterson, Desjardin et Hemmes (Peterson et al 2000
) and A. termiticola Heinem. (Heineman 1980). Psalliota nigricans Velen. 1921 (= Agaricus meleagris var. nigricans [Velen] Pilát 1951
) has been described briefly as a small species (cap 35 cm diam); the specimen drawn by Velenovsky (1921)
looks like A. parvitigrinus with a more inflated bulb. However we do not consider Psalliota nigricans as a synonym because its spores are significantly shorter (45 µm vs 5.56.7 µm for A. parvitigrinus) and this cannot be verified because the type collection does not exist. We also note its grassy site, while A. parvitigrinus was collected in wood. Agaricus velenovskyi Pilát 1968
(= Agaricus meleagris var. nigricans [Velen] Pilát sensu Pilát, 1951
, pro parte [quoad descr. & specimina], excl. typo) has a cap 511 cm diam and therefore typically is not small. This species that we suspect to be synonym or close to A. xanthodermus (see Cappelli 1984
) also can be distinguished from A. parvitigrinus by its cap, which is white and not ornamented at first, and by its grassy habitat (Pilát 1968
).
The dissimilarity analysis shows that both new species are close to A. laskibarii and A. californicus. Agaricus laskibarii differs by its larger cap and its habitat in the dunes; it differs also from A. parvitigrinus by the absence of squamules and from A. xanthodermulus by its smaller spores. Agaricus californicus, which can have a small cap diameter, differs by a pileus with a grayish brown (or "brownish-purple", according to Peck 1895
) disk without squamules (or "somewhat squamulose", according to Kerrigan 1986
) and by fainter phenolic odor and yellow discoloring on handling.
Agaricus pilatianus (Bohus) Bohus that is probably a synonym of A. iodosmus Heineman, is a large species distributed in the Mediterranean area, but a small variant was described from the Netherland (Nauta 2001
). The cylindrical stipe with a triangular annulus that characterizes this species differs from the generally bulbous stipe with a pendant membranous annulus observed in both new species.
We have known both new entities for several years, and we have observed that mycologists often have mistaken them for small or slender forms of A. moelleri, A. xanthodermus or A. pseudopratensis. This confusion also exists in the literature (i.e., we consider that the photo 544 p.192 [A. pseudopratensis var. niveus] in Arrillaga Anabitarte [2004]
represents in fact specimens of A. xanthodermulus). We primarily hesitated to describe both new entities at the varietal rank. However molecular comparisons show that both new species diverge from these three species. The level of divergence is much greater, for example, than the divergence found between sister species of section Duploannulati (Challen et al 2003
) like A. bisporus and A. subfloccosus ( J. Lange) Pilát that differ at about 1014 sequence sites (R.W. Kerrigan pers comm). Finally, all morphological and molecular comparisons reinforce the concepts of these new entities and support their elevation to the species rank.
In the Fitch phenogram A. xanthodermulus, A. parvitigrinus, A. laskibarii and A. californicus form a group. We note that this group is made up of small to medium size species. Among them, to our surprise, A. xanthodermulus and A. laskibarii are close to each other. The slight difference between the sequences of A. xanthodermulus and A. laskibarii (polymorphisms at three positions) was reinforced by the fact that the specimen of A. laskibarii was heteromorphic at four other sequence sites, while the four specimens of A. xanthodermulus had identical sequences without any heteromorphism, although the collections came from relatively distant sites in western France. The collection of A. laskibarii has been found in the same region (at about 120 km from a site of A. xanthodermulus); other collections would be useful to interpret the origin of this heteromorphism, but this species seems particularly rare. We also note that, among the three polymorphic sites for which the two species diverge, two characterize A. laskibarii while the remaining one characterizes A. xanthodermulus among all the studied species. On the other hand, the morphological differences between these two species are relatively important. They are in fact more pronounced than the differences between the two abundant species A. moelleri and A. xanthodermus, which mainly differ by the presence/absence of squamules, while their sequences differ by only two polymorphisms. Such a small divergence is of the same order of the maximum difference we observed between specimens belonging to a same species in the analysis of section Duploannulati (Challen et al 2003
). Pairs of species as close as A. laskibari/A. xanthodermulus or A. moelleri/A. xanthodermus possibly reflect relatively recent processes of speciation in the Xanthodermatei. The phylogenetic analysis of section Xanthodermatei is in progress and will let us compare better the evolutionary processes.
In conclusion, among the species of the Agaricus section Xanthodermatei there exist now in Europe four species having a cap diameter smaller than 5.5 cm (generally 34 cm), Agaricus pseudopratensis and A. endoxanthus, and two new species, A. parvitigrinus, which probably is rare, and A. xanthodermulus, which is relatively more abundant than its larger, rare sister species A. laskibarii. Phenol, p-quinol and other phenolic metabolites are constituents of A. moelleri and A. xanthodermus in sufficient quantity to account for their immediate toxicity and their phenolic odor (Gill and Strauch 1984
, Wood et al 1998
). Both new species have a phenolic odor and probably are toxic.
|
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
1 Corresponding author. E-mail: callac{at}bordeaux.inra.fr
| LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Arrillaga Anabitarte P. 2004. The genus Agaricus L.: FR. In the Basque Country and bordering areas. Munibe suplemento 17. 197 p.
Bohus G. 1971. Agaricus studies III. Ann. Hist.-nat. Mus Natl Hung 63:7782.
Cappelli A. 1984. Agaricus. Saronno, Italy: Libreria editrice Bella Giovanna. 560 p.
Challen MP, Kerrigan RW, Callac P. 2003. A phylogenetic reconstruction and emendation of Agaricus section Duploannulatae. Mycologia
95:6173.
Felsenstein J. 1993. PHYLIP: phylogeny interference package, version 3.5c. Department of Genetics, University of Washington, Seattle.
Gill M, Strauch RJ. 1984. Constituents of Agaricus xanthodermus Genevier: the first naturally endogenous azo compound and toxic phenilic metabolites. Z. Naturforsch 39c:10271029.
Heinemann P. 1980. Les genres Agaricus et Micropsalliota en Malaisie et en Indonésie. Bull Jard bot Belg 50: 368.
Higgins DG, Sharp PM. 1988. Clustal: a package for performing multiple sequence alignment on a microcomputer. Gene 73:237244.[CrossRef][Medline]
Kerrigan RW. 1986. The Agaricales (Gilled Fungi) of California. 9. Agaricaceae. Arcata, California: Mad River Press. 62 p.
Nauta MM. 2001. Agaricus L. In: Noordeloos ME, Kuyper TW, Vellinga EC, eds. Flora Agaricina Neerlandica 5. Lisse: A.A. Balkema Publishers. p 2363.
Parra LA, Arrillaga P. 2002. Agaricus laskibarii. A new species from French coastal sand-dunes of Seignosse. Doc Mycol 31(124):3338.
, Villarreal M, Esteve-Raventos F. 2002. Agaricus endoxanthus una specie tropicale trovata in Spagna. Rivista di Micologia 45(3):225233.
Peck CH. 1895. New species of Fungi. Bull Torrey Bot Club 22:198211.[CrossRef]
Peterson KR, Desjardin DE, Hemmes DE. 2000. Agaricales of the Hawaiin Islands. 6. Agaricaceae I. Agariceae : Agaricus and Melanophyllum. Sydowia 52(2):204257.
Pilát A. 1951. The bohemian species of the genus Agaricus. Acta Mus Nat Pragae 7B:1142.
. 1968. De Agarico velenovskyi sp. Nov. [= Agaricus meleagris var. nigricans (Velen.?) Pilát 1951]. Ceska Mykologie 22(2):8186.
Velenovsky J. 1921. Psalliota nigricans p 563564. In: Ceske houby. Praha. 950 p.
Wasser SP. 2002. Family Agaricaceae (Fr.) Cohn (basidiomycetes) of Israel Mycobiota. I. Tribe Agariceae Pat. ARA Gantner Verlag, Ruggell. Lichtenstein: Edit. E. Nevo and P.A. Volz. 212 p.
White TJ, Bruns T, Lee S, Taylor J. 1990. Amplification and direct sequencing of fungal ribosomal RNA genes for phylogenetics. In: Innis M, Gelfand D, Sninsky J, White T, eds. PCR Protocols: a guide to methods and applications. San Diego: Academic Press. p 315322.
Wood WF, Watson RL, Largent DL. 1998. Phenol, the odor compound from Agaricus praeclaresquamosus. Biochemilal Systematics and Ecology 26:793793.[CrossRef]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. Geml, G. A. Laursen, and D. L. Taylor Molecular diversity assessment of arctic and boreal Agaricus taxa Mycologia, July 1, 2008; 100(4): 577 - 589. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. W. Kerrigan, P. Callac, J. Guinberteau, M. P. Challen, and L. A. Parra Agaricus section Xanthodermatei: a phylogenetic reconstruction with commentary on taxa. Mycologia, November 1, 2005; 97(6): 1292 - 1315. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |