| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Department of Ecology & Environmental Science, Umeå University, SE-90187 Umeå, Sweden
David L. Hawksworth
Departamento de Biología Vegetal II, Facultad de Farmacia, Universidad Complutense, Plaza de Ramón y Cajal, Ciudad Universitaria, E-28040 Madrid, Spain
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Leptosphaeria bicolor, causal agent of a leaf scorch disease of sugar cane, is referred to the new genus Saccharicola. The ascospores are 13 transseptate and hyaline at first but become melanized and rough after release, as is the case in some members of Massarina and Lophiostoma. SSU rDNA data indicate that it is closely related to M. eburnea but is biotrophic in leaves of sugar cane and not corticolous, the ascomata are less melanized, and it has Stagonospora- and Phoma-like synanamorphs, not a Ceratophoma-like anamorph. A second species, Leptosphaeria taiwanensis, is transferred to Saccharicola. It differs in slightly larger, normally 1-septate, hyaline spores with more attenuated ends. The family Massarinaceae is resurrected to accommodate Massarina s. str., Keissleriella, Saccharicola and Helminthosporium. These genera formed a clade with 100% bootstrap support in a parsimony analysis of SSU rDNA sequences from 38 ascomycetes, 30 of them members of Pleosporales (including Melanommatales).
Key words: ascomycetes, Leptosphaeria bicolor, Massarinaceae, phylogeny, Pleosporales, SSU rDNA, morphology
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We re-examined original dried reference material and found that L. bicolor is more similar to Massarina than to Phaeosphaeria or any other genus in Dothideomycetes. In an SSU rDNA study by Liew, Aptroot and Hyde (2000)
, three Massarina species, but not L. bicolor, were among the 31 "loculoascomycetes" included. Their study indicated that Massarina was polyphyletic. The purpose of our study was to find answers to three questions: (i) Is Leptosphaeria bicolor closely related to the type species of Massarina, M. eburnea (Tul. et C. Tul.) Sacc.? (ii) If so, should it be transferred to Massarina or be accommodated in a separate genus? (iii) To which family does it belong? To answer these questions we re-examined herbarium material of L. bicolor and M. eburnea and performed a maximum-parsimony analysis of all SSU rDNA sequences from teleomorphs (63) and some anamorphs in class Dothideomycetes that were available from GenBank in April 2001.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All SSU rDNA sequences in GenBank from teleomorphs (and some anamorphs) of the Dothideomycetes, together with two members of the Chaetothyriomycetes and one of the Sordariomycetes (Table I), were aligned manually with Se-Al v.1 (Rambaut 1996
). The latter (Neurospora crassa) was used as outgroup in maximum-parsimony analyses performed with PAUP 4.0b7 (Swofford 2001). Gaps were coded as missing data. Trees were obtained by heuristic search (100 replicates, random addition sequence and TBR branch swapping algorithms). Bootstrap values for nodes were computed from 500 replicates. The TreeBase study accession number is S865; and the matrix accession number is M1402.
|
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Molecular data
We aligned all SSU rDNA sequences from teleomorphs and some anamorphs in the Dothideomycetes available in GenBank, using Se-Al. In a first preliminary parsimony analysis (not shown), with two outgroup taxa in Chaetothyriomycetes and one in Sordariomycetes, we found that Leptosphaeria bicolor appeared with a strong bootstrap (BT) support in a clade of perithecioid taxa, most of which currently are accommodated in Pleosporales (including Melanommatales), Dothideales and Capnodiales. Taxa in Pleosporales formed one subclade, those in Dothideales and Capnodiales another subclade, both with strong BT support. We performed a BLAST search for the sequences that were most similar to the SSU rDNA of L. bicolor. Almost all taxa from that search were members of the Pleosporales clade. The hyphomycetes Helminthosporium solani and H. velutinum had the most similar sequences, as already reported by Olivier et al (2000)
.
In a second parsimony search we excluded Dothideomycetes taxa that, based on the first parsimony analysis, obviously were not related closely to L. bicolor, viz. members of Myriangiales, Patellariales and some genera with uncertain relationships, e.g., Acrospermum (Winka and Eriksson 2000
) and Aliquandostipite (Inderbitzin et al 2001
). Excluded also were many taxa in genera with several closely related species that differed very little in their SSU rDNA sequences. Many of the sequences in the alignment were about 1700 bp, and only a short part at the ends of each gene was lacking. However, some sequences were little more than 1000 bp (from near the 5' end of the gene).
This second heuristic analysis (100 repl.) of 1708 characters (225 phylogenetically informative) in 37 taxa resulted in 12 equally most-parsimonious trees (MPTs). The consensus tree (Fig. 3) resembled that from the first broader analysis but with slightly different BT values. All members of the Dothideomycetes clustered in one clade with 97% BT support. The two members of Chaetothyriomycetes formed a separate clade with 100% BT support. The Dothideomycetes clade again consisted of two subclades, both with 99% BT support, viz. one with all members of Pleosporales, the other with members of Dothideales and Capnodiales. The Pleosporales clade of 30 taxa was not very well resolved. Almost all of the differences between the 12 MPTs were in this clade, and six branches collapsed in the consensus tree. It also contains genera, such as Melanomma and Massaria, which have been placed in the orders Melanommatales and Pyrenulales, respectively. Inclusion of more taxa representing these two orders might be useful in resolving the phylogeny of the clade. However, some subclades received a strong BT support, six of them with 95100% support. One of the subclades that received 100% BT support consisted of Leptosphaeria bicolor, Massarina eburnea and the two Helminthosporium species. The position of Leptosphaeria bicolor and the type species of Leptosphaeria, L. doliolum (Pers.) Ces. et De Not., is of particular interest because we were able to confirm the results of some previous studies that indicated that Leptosphaeria bicolor is not closely related to the generic type Leptosphaeria doliolum (Morales et al 1995
, Dong et al 1998
, Olivier et al 2000
, Tehler et al 2000
).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key observations in our morphological studies of L. bicolor and M. eburnea are: (i) M. eburnea, as most other species in Massarina s. lat., occurs in bark or on wood of shrubs and trees. A few Massarina species are saprotrophs on other substrates, e.g., grass culms, canes of Rubus and leaves of Lycopodium, but it is uncertain now whether these species are closely related to M. eburnea. Leptosphaeria bicolor is a perthotroph that occurs only in discolored dead areas in living leaves of Saccharum officinarum. (ii) The wall of the ascomata usually is melanized irregularly in Massarina and opaque black near the ostiole. The ascomatal cell walls are dark brownish in L. bicolor, but the ostiolar region is not opaque black. (iii) A ring is visible in the apex of M. eburnea asci in mounts stained with Cotton blue (Eriksson 1981
, Fig. 103B). No ring was seen in the ascal apex of L. bicolor mounted in Cotton blue or Congo red. (iv) The ascospore wall is about 11.5 µm in M. eburnea but is somewhat thicker at the septa, which are thick in the peripheral parts and gradually thinner toward the central pore (Eriksson 1981
, Fig. 103C). Thus, the locules are lenticular. In L. bicolor the spore wall and septa are of equal and even thickness, c. 1 µm. (v) The ascospores are consistently hyaline in M. eburnea. We have searched for melanized spores on the bark near the ostiole in this species but have found none. In old ascospores of L. bicolor, the septa also are melanized and the central pore is visible in the each septum. That feature recalls a septal pore in Pyrenidium actinellum Nyl. (Dacampiaceae, Hawksworth 1980
, 1983
) and Navicella pileata (Tode) Fabre (Massariaceae; Eriksson 1981
, Fig. 99H). However, pores can be demonstrated also in species with hyaline spores if a stain is added to the mount, e.g., in Clathrospora heterospora (De Not.) Wehm. (Eriksson 1967
, Fig. 2m). A central pore probably always is present in spore septa and thus not a phylogenetically important character. (vi) The perispore is thick in M. eburnea and divided at the primary septum (Eriksson 1981
, Fig. 103C). No perispore was seen in L. bicolor, even in young ascospores. (vii) M. eburnea, has a Ceratophoma-like anamorph (Bose 1981). The anamorph of L. bicolor is Stagonospora-like, but a Phoma-like anamorph also has been reported (Venkatasubbaiah et al 1988
). Many species of Phaeosphaeria have a Stagonospora anamorph, but the conidia are more numerous and smaller in comparison to the size of the pycnidia than are those of the anamorph of L. bicolor. Stagonospora conidia are comparatively much fewer and larger in L. bicolor (see Kaiser et al 1979
, Fig. 5E). Also, Câmara et al (2002)
have argued that the "Stagonospora" anamorphs of Phaeosphaeria are different from that of L. bicolor. One of the 43 Massarina species, accepted by Aptroot (1998)
, M. arundinacea (Sow.) Leuchtm., has been reported to have a Stagonospora anamorph (S. elegans (Berk.) Sacc.), but the connection seems never to have been proven, and the conidia of this fungus are very large (5284 x 8.514 µm, Sutton 1980
: 108) and it is highly improbable that the presence of a Stagonospora-like fungus in L. bicolor and M. arundinacea (unproven) is a synapomorphy. The latter species has ascospores that are similar to immature Lophiostoma spores, and it might be related to that genus.
Molecular data
As mentioned above, our morphological studies indicate that L. bicolor is closely related to Massarina. In a molecular study of ascostromatic taxa, Liew et al (2000)
found that Massarina might be a polyphyletic genus. They did not include L. bicolor in their study. In our analysis of a broader set of taxa, we obtained a phylogram similar to that in Olivier et al: two strongly supported subclades (A and B) that formed a clade that was the sister clade of a large group containing Leptosphaeria s. str., Phaeosphaeria, Pleospora, etc. Some other taxa were located close to, but not in, these clades and will require further studies (Massariosphaeria phaeospora, etc.), but adding more taxa to the analysis probably will not influence the stability of Clade A.
Clade A (100%) contained L. bicolor and the two Helminthosporium species mentioned above and the generic type Massarina eburnea. This clade might be referred to as Massarinaceae Munk, a family name that has been treated as a synonym of Lophiostomataceae (e.g., Eriksson and Yue 1986
, Eriksson 1999
).
Clade B (96%) contained six taxa, Cucurbidothis pityophila and Venturia liriodendrii (as in Olivier et al), but also two Paraphaeosphaeria species (P. michotii and P. pilleata), Phaeodothis winteri and Montagnula opulenta (syn. Didymosphaerella opulenta, Barr 2001
). The two latter species were included by Barr (2001)
in her new family Montagnulaceae. Whether the other species in Clade B have any specific morphological traits in common with the Montagnulaceae is as yet unclear. Paraphaeosphaeria michotii is the type species of Paraphaeosphaeria, and, as pointed out by Câmara et al (2001)
, the genus might be polyphyletic. Paraphaeosphaeria pilleata is closely related. Both species have small, 2-septate ascospores. Other species in the genus clustered with Leptosphaeria, Phaeosphaeria and Cucurbitaria and might require a new generic name.
Molecular characters indicate that Leptosphaeria bicolor is closely related to Massarina eburnea, the type species of Massarina, but there are several morphological differences between the two species. They are best accommodated in separate genera, hence, L. bicolor is transferred to the new genus Saccharicola. L. taiwanensis is closely related and also is accommodated in Saccharicola.
Saccharicola D. Hawksw. et O.E. Erikss. gen. nov.
Ascomata pseudothecia, scattered, arising singly in dead spots of leaves, immersed, subglobose, black, ostiole papillate; walls composed of a few layers of dark brown pseudoparenchymatous cells. Hamathecium of filiform, branched, rarely anastomosing pseudoparaphyses. Asci subcylindrical or elongate-clavate, bitunicate, 8-spored. Ascospores distichously arranged in the asci, broadly fusiform, inequilateral, 13-septate, hyaline to pale brown in the asci, brownish and usually finely warted after release, penultimate cell inflated, often darker than the other cells and sometimes dark brown. Conidiomata pycnidia, similar to Stagonospora.
Typus: Saccharicola bicolor (D. Hawksw., W. Kaiser et Ndimande) D. Hawksw. et O.E. Erikss. (HOLOTYPUS).
Basionym: Leptosphaeria bicolor D. Hawksw., W. Kaiser et Ndimande, in Kaiser et al, Mycologia 71: 483 (1979).
Type: KENYA: near Nairobi, on leaves of Saccharum officinarum, 24.viii.1977, W.J. Kaiser (HOLOTYPE IMI 215888; ISOTYPES BPI, DAOM, H).
Other collection studied: KENYA: Mumias (W. Kenya), Stagonospora sp. isolated from Saccharum officinarum, 3.vi.1977, W.J. Kaiser (IMI 214025).
Descriptions: Kaiser et al (1979)
, Punithalingam (1983)
, Sivanesan (1984)
, Sivanesan and Waller (1986)
.
|
Type: TAIWAN: Taichung, on leaves of Saccharum officinarum, 4.ii.1953, W.Y. Yen (ISOTYPE BPI 621856).
Descriptions: Yen and Chi (1952)
, Shoemaker and Babcock (1989)
.
Camara et al (2002)
found in their ITS analyses that L. bicolor is very closely related to L. taiwanensis J.M. Yen et C.C. Chi, another species on Saccharum, and another unnamed species on Miscanthus, a grass genus related to Saccharum. There were no differences between the sequences from different isolates of L. taiwanensis, but the sequence from L. bicolor differed from these in 26 positions. Shoemaker and Babcock (1989)
examined type material of L. taiwanenis and said the ascospores were hyaline and 1-septate, although some older spores appeared "3-septate from separation of protoplasts." Therefore, they transferred the species to Didymella. From their excellent description and illustrations and our studies of type material, it is clear that the fungus is more similar to young specimens of Saccharicola than to Didymella, which have larger peridial cells and no tendency to phragmoseptation. The two Saccharicola species are found in dead spots on leaves of Saccharum. They can be identified only under the microscope. S. taiwanensis has 1-septate hyaline ascospores that are more attenuated toward the ends than the spores of S. bicolor, which, moreover, are smaller. Sivanesan (1984)
said the spores were "hyaline and brown" and 4046 x 6.512.5 µm, whereas Shoemaker and Babcock (1989)
gave the spore size of L. taiwanensis as 4456 x 1113 µm, and whose observations are in agreement with our studies. The spores of L. bicolor measure 2942 x 811 µm.
There has been a controversy about the identity of the anamorph of L. taiwanenis, either Cercospora taiwanensis T. Matsumoto et W. Yamam. or Stagonospora tainanensis Hsieh (see Shoemaker and Babcock 1989
). Further collecting and cultural studies are needed to confirm Hsieh's (1979)
studies that demonstrated Phoma and Stagonospora synanamorphs.
Our results support those of previous studies suggesting: (1) the genus Massarina is heterogenous (Liew et al 2000
). The type species can be accommodated in the family Massarinaceae (Pleosporales). Among the other species is the type of the genus Bertiella (Sacc.) Sacc et Sydow (Eriksson and Yue 1986
, Aptroot 1998
), which probably is closely related to the Lophiostomataceae. (2) The genus Paraphaeosphaeria is heterogeneous (Câmara et al 2001
). One fraction seems to be related to the Montagnulaceae; the other is closest to Leptosphaeria or Phaeosphaeria. (3) Kirschsteiniothelia might be heterogenous. Material identified as the type species, Kirschsteiniothelia aethiops (Berk. et Curtis) D. Hawksw. (Hawksworth 1985
), clustered with unitunicate pyrenomycetes, and a BLAST search listed only members of the Sordariomycetes. More information on this sequence and the voucher material must be examined and the misidentification excluded before any changes are made to the generic concept. K. elaterascens might be closely related to Helicascus kanaloanus, and these two species will require restudy and closer morphological comparison. K. maritima does not seem to be related to any of the two other species discussed above.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Accepted for publication September 9, 2002.
| LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Barr ME., 2001 Montagnulaceae, a new family in the Pleosporales, and lectotypification of Didymosphaerella.. Mycotaxon 77:193-200
Bose SK., 1961 Studies on Massarina Sacc. and related genera. Phytopath Z 41:151-211
Câmara MPS, Palm ME, Berkum P van, Stewart EL., 2001 Systematics of Paraphaeosphaeria: a molecular and morphological approach. Mycol Res 105:41-56
, , , O'Neill NR., 2002 Molecular phylogeny of Leptosphaeria and Phaeosphaeria. Mycologia 94:630-640
Dong JW, Chen WD, Crane JL., 1998 Phylogenetic studies of the Leptosphaeriaceae, Pleosporaceae and some other Loculoascomycetes based on nuclear ribosomal DNA sequences. Mycol Res 102:151-156
Eriksson OE., 1967 On graminicolous pyrenomycetes from Fennoscandia. 1. Dictyosporous species. Ark Bot, Ser. 2 6:339-379
. 1981 The families of bitunicate ascomycetes. Opera Botanica 60:1-220
. 1999 Outline of Ascomycota1999. Myconet 3:1-88
, Yue JZ., 1986 Bertiella (Sacc.) Sacc. & Sydow a synonym of Massarina Sacc. Mycotaxon 27:247-253
Hawksworth DL., 1980 Notes on some fungi occurring on Peltigera, with a key to accepted species. Trans Br Mycol Soc 74:363-386
. 1983 The identity of Pyrenidium actinellum Nyl. Trans Br Mycol Soc 80:547-549
. 1985 Kirschsteiniothelia, a new genus for the Microthelia incrustans-group (Dothideales). Bot J Linn Soc 91:181-202
Holm L., 1957 Études taxonomiques sur les Pléosporacées. Symb Bot Upsal 14:1-188
Hsieh WH., 1979 The causal organism of sugar cane leaf blight. Mycologia 71:892-898
Hyde KD., 1995 The genus Massarina, with a description of M. eburnea and an annotated list of Massarina names. Mycol Res 99:291-296
Inderbitzin P, Landvik S, Abdel-Wahab MA, Berbee ML., 2001 Aliquandostipitaceae, a new family for two new tropical ascomycetes with unusually wide hyphae and dimorphic ascomata. Am J Bot 88:52-61
Kaiser WJ, Ndimande BN, Hawksworth DL., 1979 Leaf-scorch disease of sugar cane in Kenya caused by a new species of Leptosphaeria. Mycologia 71:479-492
Leuchtmann A., 1985 Über Phaeosphaeria Miyake und andere bitunicate Ascomyceten mit mehrfach querseptierten Ascosporen. Sydowia 37:93-163
Liew ECY, Aptroot A, Hyde KD., 2000 Phylogenetic significance of the pseudoparaphyses in loculoascomycete taxonomy. Mol Phyl Evol 16:392-402[Medline]
Morales VM, Jasalavich CA, Pelcher LE, Petrie GA, Taylor JL., 1995 Phylogenetic relationships among several Leptosphaeria species based on their ribosomal DNA sequences. Mycol Res 99:593-603
Olivier C, Berbee ML, Shoemaker RA, Loria R., 2000 Molecular phylogenetic support from ribosomal DNA sequences for origin of Helminthosporium from Leptosphaeria-like loculoascomycete ancestors. Mycologia 92:736-746
Punithalingam E., 1983 Leptosphaeria bicolor. CMI Descr Path Fungi Bact, No. 771
Rambaut A., 1996 Se-Al sequence alignment editor. Oxford, University of Oxford, Department of Zoology: Distributed by the author: http://evolve.zoo.ox.ac.uk/ (link: Software)
Shoemaker RA, Babcock CE., 1989 Phaeosphaeria. Can J Bot 67:1500-1599
Silva-Hanlin DMW, Hanlin RT., 1999 Small subunit ribosomal RNA gene phylogeny of several loculoascomycetes and its taxonomic implications. Mycol Res 103:153-160
Sivanesan A., 1984 The Bitunicate Ascomycetes and their Anamorphs. J. Cramer, Vaduz
Sivanesan A, Waller JM., 1986 Sugar cane diseases. Phytopath Papers 29:1-88
Sutton BC., 1980 The Coelomycetes. Kew: Commonwealth Mycological Institute
Swofford DL., 1999 PAUP* phylogenetic analysis using parsimony (*and other methods). Sunderland, Massachusetts: Sinauer Associates
Tehler A, Farris JS, Lipscomb DL, Källersjö M., 2000 Phylogenetic analyses of the fungi based on large rDNA data sets. Mycologia 92:459-474
Venkatasubbaiah P, Kohmoto K, Otani H, Hamasaki T, Nakajima H, Hokama K., 1988 Two phytotoxins from Stagonospora sacchari causing leaf scorch of sugercane. Ann Phytopath Soc Japan 53:335-344
Winka K, Eriksson OE., 2000 Adding to the bitunicate puzzle. In: K. Winka, ed. Phylogenetic relationships within the Ascomycota based on 18S rDNA sequences. [PhD Thesis]. Umeå, Sweden: Umeå University
Yen WY, Chi CC., 1952 Studies on leaf blight of sugar cane (I). J Sugar cane Res Taiwan 6:191-215 [Not seen]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. L. Schoch, R. A. Shoemaker, K. A. Seifert, S. Hambleton, J. W. Spatafora, and P. W. Crous A multigene phylogeny of the Dothideomycetes using four nuclear loci Mycologia, November 1, 2006; 98(6): 1041 - 1052. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |